bipolar vs. manic depression ?
Q.I just stayed awake late to finish reading "Unquiet Mind" by Kay Redfield Jamison. At the end of the book she goes into how the newer term "bipolar" was invented in order to take away some of the stigma of these disease...the term bipolar does not adequately describe the disease. I know these seem like a frivolous post but I am curious about how others take this. Bipolar does not exactly offend me but I prefer manic-depression. To me the name of this disease should describe in more vivid terms..and if we make the name softer and more "politically correct" then people won't realize the hell it is to deal with this disease.
A.Personally, I prefer Bipolar Disorder. The Manic-Depressive term has a lot of very negative connotations with people. Like the term, 'maniac.' I just don't like it. Bipolar Disorder sounds more like a medical condition (which it is) than some bizarre form of mental illness, which is how people tend to perceive Manic-Depression. People tend to be a lot more accepting of my condition if I tell them I'm bipolar than if I tell them I'm manic-depressive. Manic-depression sounds scary and dangerous. Bipolar disorder sounds a little safer to 'normies,' and allows them to interact with you without fear. I've run into so many people who think that all manic-depressives run around with guns, commiting random acts of insane violence. I feel the same as you! Not many people know, or even seem to care about this illness. Maybe someone changed it on the account of that. I wonder who changed it, being a doctor, or something else. Everytime I tell someone I'm Bipolar, their like, "What's that?". Then I say manic-depressive. Anyway, I feel the same! I think that bipolar does have less stigma associated with it than manic depression. In part I think that when people don't stigmatize it as much it is because they just ignore it because they don't understand what is being said. In the long run, I believe name jumping to prevent stigma is not the solution - the stigma must be fought at its root. For myself, I prefer bipolar as when that term is used there seems to be less of a focus on depression. Often, I have felt that manic depression was treated as a special "adaptation or alternative" of depression, a depression, like some of the other modified depressions. This is problematic for me as with eight years experience of this disease I have not experienced a depressive episode - manic depression, manic only sounds weird. In some sense I view my "poles" as mania and hypermania/"normality", which is a better fit in terms of terms. Even so, I sometimes use manic depression also. Before the response comes. Let me say that I understand that longer term I may suffer a depressive episode and I know that this is one of the unknowns with the illness.
Other Questions :
Are antidepressants endangering our children?
Antidepressants for school phobias, anti-psychotics for children who refuse to obey the rules. A generation ago, parents worried about giving their children too much Baby Aspirin. Today, psychiatric drugs rank among the top five medicines p...
Living Without Depression and Manic Depression:Online chat transcript 1/1/01 ?
I have been suffering with Bipolar Disorder all my life, but was diagnosed in 1986. After my second big crash, my therapist suggested that I buy your book The Depression Workbook. I was skeptical, but reluctantly picked it up. When I got to cer...
Coping With Clinical Depression?
I have the suspect that at least some (perhaps most) cases of incurable depression may start as depression caused by some negative experience, then the patient starts taking antidepressants which alter his or her brain chemistry and make him or...
Wife wants divorce, due to post pardum depression
Last week my wife came out and told me that she hasn't loved me or been happy since my daughter was born. She was diagnosed with post partum depression last year and only took the prescription for a week. She feels like she needs to be alone....
Anyone here with chronic pain and depression?
It seems that since my car accident in March, my depression has increased. I'm not dying, but it feels that way. I'm going through PT, and now my doc has given me Ultracet for pain (no more Vicodin for me, he said. Too addicting, but it reall...