Myths of "Dependency," Self-Reliance, and Clinical Depression ?
Q.For many folks this just is not true. Most people occasionally become depressed due to the viscissitudes of life: death of someone close, loss of job, divorce, moving to someplace different, all are recognized at situations that may prompt situational depression in almost anyone. Normally this kind of depression will resolve after some amount of time with or without intervention. It is not pleasant, but it is not clinical depression. [Forgive me if my terminology is not medically correct.
A.A lot of doctors still do not seem to think this way. They want patients to use meds temporarily with expectation of stopping it. That may be appropriate if the disorder they are treating is situational, but not for patients who relate life histories of repeated depressive episodes. It is surprising but unfortunately true that doctors frequently are slow to learn of research developments in undertanding of depression and the available treatments for it. They may convey the attitude that patients ought just pull themselves up by bootstraps. THis is likely just to make the clinical depressive feel worse, since we are unable to pull that maneouver off. We need our medications, and probably always will. Even if we have good periods, going off the meds seems to be dangerous for us, too often leading to major crashes with accompanying crises. Being able to proclaim ourselves to be "drug free" may not be worth the apparent consequences. i think people's attitudes are changing, albeit slowly, to understand the illness. there seems to be a duality now in many people's thinking about depression - on one hand, they understand intellectually how endogenous depression works but they also have ingrained beliefs and ideas about depression that they have heard all their life. Another thing that I think complicates this is the fact that the two types of depression, situational and endogenous, do exist. They must look very similar to most people. I'm sure we must all hope that our depression will be just an episode, that we will recover from it, and that we will "go on" with our lives. I think it can take years for a person to accept that their depression is likely going to be a life-long problem. I also think that there is psychological denial by people in general, depressed or non-depressed, that any kind of chronic illness even exists. I suppose this is because of fear that if it can happen to someone else, it could happen to them.
Other Questions :
FREE: "Coping With Depression" Report!! ?
I am letting you know about a new book on coping with depression and hopefully beating it! I have lived with a couple of very close family members who had depression and can sympathise with all who have this debilitating disease.If you want to r...
Can anxiety/depression do this to me?
I have experienced anxiety and depression in the past, typically related to something going on in my life at the time (death of a friend, challenges with my handicapped child, etc). However, what I'm going through now is completely new to me. ...
Myths of "Dependency," Self-Reliance, and Clinical Depression ?
For many folks this just is not true. Most people occasionally become depressed due to the viscissitudes of life: death of someone close, loss of job, divorce, moving to someplace different, all are recognized at situations that may prompt situ...
Fwd: New Self-Rating Depression Scale Is Brief, Valid and Reliable ?
The Brief Depression Scale is a valid and reliable screening and outcome measure for depression in primary and secondary care settings, researchers report.Consisting of ten items, the Brief Depression Scale has been validated in 275 psychiatric...
antidepressant medications and running?
I'm starting counseling/treatment for depression and possible anxiety/anger issues, and may be prescribed antidepressant medication. I was on Elavil three times before--the first time in 1983/early 1984, then in 1987, and the last time in earl...