sleep deprivation for depression advice required ?
Q.Like M.. says, sleep deprivation is not a sustainable strategy for alleviating depression. One or two short nights may help, but expect to go downhill if you keep it up. If you'd like to list the things (including medications) you've tried so far, and what effects they have had, we might be able to suggest some alternatives. For that matter, what are your symptoms, and are they related in some fashion to anything in your life?
A.I have read on many websites that even a single days sleep deprivation can reduce depression in about 60% of depressed people. When I stay up all night, I am very stressed the following day, and make a lot of mistakes. So, as a compromise I was thinking of waking myself up when REM sleep starts, as I read somewhere that not having any REM sleep is also a valid method of fighting depression. What I want to know is: Is there any way of waking myself just before the start of REM sleep, either with a drug, or an electrical device? And, since I'm doing this at home, I don't have access to one of those devices that you see on tv with electrodes attached to your skull. If it is possible to wake myself during REM sleep, then how many nights do you reckon I would have to do it per week, in order to have an antidepressant effect? I am also taking Remeron and Lamatrogine,these have had zero effect so far; I read that sleep deprivation can activate antidepressants which are not working. Do you believe there's any truth in this claim? I have tried many things to fight depression,and they have all been completely useless, so I'm very skeptical that sleep deprivation is going to help even in the slightest, but it's something I want to give a try. i have found sleep deprivation to have some benefit; eg a normal 8 hrs, then 3-4 hours the next day. tried NO sleep, found worries less adhesive but the fatigue pretty much cancelled the benefit. 6 hours, no help. 3 seemed to be the ideal, although your experience might be different. also, this only seemed to work for one night...continued deprivation wasn't helpful at all.
Other Questions :
Depression Help? Is there any?
My friend, an RN, tells me that I have situational depression. About 4 times a year I get depressed and feel badly for days. My life is not that bad really compared to other people I see who do not seem depressed but sure have a right to be. ...
Medication and Pregnancy ?
When I mentioned to my p-doc that I wanted to have another child, he suggested I go off the drug (Klonopin) and put me on a taper schedule. I tapered from 1.25mgs to .75mgs with no problem, but my anxiety level shoots up when I try to go lower....
new member-clinical depression & effects on pregnancy questions ?
I was diagnosed with clinical depression in 1992 at age 22, after dropping out of college due to problems associated with my depressive state. My family practice doctor put me on Prozac and I began counseling. Looking back, I believe I began ...
Squiggles and depression ?
I have noticed that people who get depression also have anxiety. In my case, this is redundant as I am bipolar and the "polarities" are already recognized by medical classification. But, in the case of "unipolars" or just plain depressed ...
Major Depression & BiPolar Disorder may be variations of same disorder ?
Patients with recurrent major depression may experience several manic or hypomanic symptoms throughout their lifetimes, suggesting that major depression and bipolar depression are not two distinct disorders.Are major depressive disorder and bip...