Do antidepressants really work?
Q.Do antidepressants work ?
A.Many people feel certain that antidepressants have helped them and may even have saved their lives. They might think it was naïve or dangerous even to ask whether antidepressants work, and almost all health-care professionals would agree. By admitting the possibility they might not, the question flies in the face of seemingly rock-solid medical opinion and, whatever the answer, might promote loss of confidence in the effectiveness of treatment. This could add to the problems of depressed patients, put further demands on clinicians and health services and damage commercial interests and reputations. But the reason for asking if antidepressants work is not to try to prove that they don’t; it is to review briefly the evidence that insists they do. Much of this evidence is based on carefully conducted clinical studies and trials, but what is actually being tested ? What is the "depression" these drugs treat ? What are "antidepressants" and what effects do they have ? What does "work" really mean, and how sound is the evidence they do ? The answer to the central question fundamentally depends on these and other matters of definition and interpretation. The question "Do antidepressants work ?" also provides a framework for thinking about a range of underlying issues, including the relationships between nature & nurture, sickness & health and benefit & risk. Questions also arise about business conduct and the roles of money and influence; about organisational imperatives versus health goals; about the quality of science and the basis of trust; and about the effectiveness of law and regulation. Similar questions were addressed in an earlier study (Medawar, 1992) which discussed the relationships between doctors, pharmaceutical companies, government and consumers - as reflected in the habitual prescribing of dependence-producing drugs for anxiety, insomnia, depression and related problems that go by a thousand other names. Over the past 200 years, doctors have prescribed an almost uninterrupted succession of "addictive" drugs, always in the belief they would not cause dependence or that patients would be mainly responsible if they did. In the beginning were alcohol and opium, then morphine, heroin, and cocaine; alongside were chloral; numerous bromides, barbiturates and related compounds, and then a score of benzodiazepine tranquillisers. In their day, all these drugs have been prescribed as sedatives for mental distress, and except for alcohol, also as weaning treatments for addiction to other drugs on the list.
Other Questions :
Clinical Depression In Teens?
experts had access to clinical trials performed by pharmaceutical companies that were previously confidential. At a 1991 hearing on the safety of Prozac in adults, doctors had reviewed only the limited number of studies that the drug companie...
Atypical Depression Actually Very Typica 1/23/02 ?
other newer medications are often the first line choice for depression treatment due to their favorable side-effect profiles, very little is yet known about how well these work for the patient with atypical depression. What is known is that pa...
Alternative Treatment for Clinical Depression ?
Several years ago, after being treated with Paxil for clinical depression, I started doing some research. I was not happy with the effects of Paxil. Altho it did help my depression, it did nothing for other symptoms I was having, and I started...
Chronic Neuropathic Pain etc. ?
I hated Neurontin. It exacerbated all my symptoms and I will never take it again. I know it has helped a lot of patients but not me....I found Neurontin exacerbated all my symptoms. I hated it. The only thing that works for me are narcotics. This...
antidepressants and adolescent suicide ?
What about alcohol? Binge drinking is a significant predictor of adolescent suicide.(6) But is depression the cause of binge drinking and suicide, or does drinking drive depression and suicide? The answer seems to depend on gender. Modelling of...